Best sourdoughWATTB88/100££Sourdough pizzaVegetarian options

Honest Crust

Photo: Honest Crust Sourdough Pizza · Google

Our verdict · Manchester's sourdough pioneer, with an ingredient-led menu that changes with the seasons.

Go if

You prefer a long-fermented sourdough base and a communal food-hall setting.

Skip it if

You want a quiet, bookable table, as it trades from a shared-seating food hall with limited days.

Plan your visit

Honest Crust

WATTB Score

88/ 100

Our research-based editorial assessment.

How we score →

From ~£11 a pizza (indicative); around £20-25pp

Indicative price at the time of review.

Book a table Get directions

Honest Crust has been making sourdough pizza since 2013, when it started as a pop-up in Ramsbottom, and is credited as an early mover in Manchester's pizza revival. Its trademark is a naturally leavened base fermented for a minimum of 48 hours using a blend of Shipton Mill flours, topped with Italian tomatoes and mozzarella plus rotating specials built around named British growers and charcuterie suppliers, so the menu shifts with what is in season. It ranks third rather than higher because it operates from the communal Mackie Mayor food hall (and Altrincham Market House): the setting is a draw but you cannot reserve a private table, seating is shared and opening days can be limited. Choose it over the Neapolitan picks when you specifically want a longer-fermented, tangier sourdough crust and a lively market-hall setting.

The good & the bad

Pros

Distinctive 48-hour naturally leavened sourdough base from a genuine local pioneer
Ingredient-led, seasonal specials from named British suppliers
Set inside the historic Mackie Mayor food hall, a popular Manchester venue

Cons

Food-hall model means shared seating and no private-table bookings
Limited and variable opening days, so check ahead and plan for peak-time queues

How it compares

Pick	WATTB Score	Price	Best for
1.Rudy's Pizza Napoletana	91/100	From ~£11 for a margherita (indicative); around £20-25pp with a drink	overall
2.Noi Quattro	89/100	From ~£9 a pizza (indicative); around £20pp	Neapolitan purists
3.Honest CrustThis pick	88/100	From ~£11 a pizza (indicative); around £20-25pp	sourdough
4.Nell's Pizza	85/100	From ~£4 a slice (indicative); whole pies from ~£12	groups and late-night slices
5.Ciaooo Pizzeria	84/100	From ~£9 a pizza (indicative); around £20pp	value